Milani Amore Matte Lip Creme Review & Swatches

Tuesday, November 15, 2016

Sponsored: I was sent some Milani Amore Matte Lip Creme liquid lipsticks to review. I've reviewed a number of Milani products in the past and have been VERY pleased. But this year, I noticed a number of bloggers & YouTubers complaining about the formula of some of their newer products (foundation, lipstick etc.). I experienced several problems with these. The first problem I experienced was when I swatched the liquid lipstick on the back of my hand. If you look at my initial (hand) swatch, you'll notice they look good wet. However, when the colors dried down (middle hand picture) there was a lot of patchiness & unevenness. The second problem I experienced was with the packaging. I found there was way too much product dispensed on both the applicator and wand. When applying these to my lips, I had to be very careful not to apply too much (which was difficult & nearly impossible). This liquid lipstick applies very liquidity & thick and can be messy. The third problem I experienced, was getting EVEN COVERAGE! You're dealing with a liquid lipstick that dries super fast, but is patchy. So layering can be challenging. Matte lipsticks were all the rage this year. I've mentioned in countless other reviews, that I'm not a fan of all of them because of their tendency to be super dry. These by Milani are DRY! These come in 28 colors! From very light shades to darker ones as you see here. These also come in a Metallic formula! I bet those are better, but I haven't read any reviews. I quickly linked a couple of other reviews, so you can weigh your options (here, here, and here). I noticed some patchiness in their lip swatches as well. As with fashion, beauty companies are expected to come out with new products OFTEN. Personally, I think they're coming out with way too much. MAC has gone ballistic with their collections. This year, I've witnessed really good makeup companies sacrificing the quality of their products for quantity. It's truly sad to see. Beauty enthusiasts are recognizing these problems and are more cautious now with their purchases.

Sweet-Bittersweet-NotSweet
supersweet(run & buy it) sweet(really good,buy it) bittersweet(ok, issues)not sweet(not good,don't buy this stuff) 
  Milani Amore Matte Lip Creme's are Not Sweet


From L-R: Dearest (37) which is a deep merlot , Beautiful (34) which is a true red and 
Emotion (32) which is a reddish brown

No Comments Yet, Leave Yours!

Lizzy Fresh said...

Woooow, I thought I had read that wrong, 28 shades?!? That's massive for a drugstore release, and makes it so much more saddening that the formula is bad too. Hopefully they get on top of it and make some improvements because even just the 3 shades you've shown are beautiful colors and I'd love to see such a big range and amazing brand do the formula some justice!

eightbitbeauty.blogspot.com

Yiotou_La said...

Too bad these do not work for you! I tried the Allure colour and it worked fine, it didn't dry my lips like other liquid lipsticks I tried in the past and the colour is amazing, more of a spring shade! These three shades you got look great, too bad about the formula!

Yiota
PinkDaisyLoves

Ollyvia Laura said...

whoaaah so pretty lipsticks

// MY BEAUTY & TRAVEL BLOG //

Emmylou MW said...

That's too bad about the quality of these, Kim:( But dang...you look so great in these three shades! I usually do like Milani and am quite disappointed to hear about this new release. And I agree about these new releases from beauty companies! I find MAC has one, like....what? Every week! :P I exaggerate, but you know what I mean. Everytime I go to Sephora, the new products always overwhelm me.

Lenya said...

Beautiful review, Kim. And now I am glad I didn't get them. I bought quite a lot of the brilliant and shine lip glosses by Milani and boy was I disappointed. They are so sticky and they don't last even as long as an hour, tho.
xox
Lenya
FashionDreams&Lifestyle

Md Amirul Islam said...

lovely post.........
I like and subscribe your channel, Please Subscribe my channel
DailyBDPeace: http://bit.ly/2dBw9fw

Shira said...

That's a shame! I heard a couple of people liked this formula so I wonder if it varies by shade. I like you in that bright middle shade!

http://asequinloveaffair.com

Cee said...

I've never tried Milani products specifically, but I am always very wary of liquid lipsticks in dark shades - I find they're incredibly hard to apply evening and always dry down to an odd, patchy finish. I've had the same problems with Color Pop and Smashbox. Thanks for an honest review, Kim!
xox,
Cee

Vale ♥ said...

Amazing shades, I am so intrigued by Milani makeup, never tried it tho also cause it's hard to find here in Italy ! Kisses

Fashion and Cookies - fashion and beauty blog

Rowena @ rolala loves said...

The colors look really pretty so it's a shame there was such a huge misstep with the formulation and packaging. I understand that companies have to continually come out with new products but to put quantity over quality is never a good way to go and that goes for us as consumers as well. I know I'd rather have one good lipstick than 10 crappy ones. Thanks for your honest thoughts Kim!

Elizabeth Rose Hisle said...

I am so disappointed to hear this. I love Milani... their blushes and regular lipsticks are great, and even some of their mascaras are good in my opinion. I hope this will not be a trend for their brand.

waltzandwillow.com

Lorena said...

Total fail from what I read Kim - and like you say, its awful they are sacrificing quality for quantity.

Tanya Dufour said...

Oh bummer! I have been looking for this lip cream in the color Lovely because it looked so pretty! I think I'll skip now as I hate patchy lip products! Thanks for the honest review!

The Radiant Cherie said...

Aww, I really like these! Might also try them!

Ina - http://theradiantcherie.com/

Jalisa Giron said...

That's such a shame that the formula isn't good on these because the colors are so beautiful! You can defiantly see the patchiness, especially on the burgundy and brown shades. I've always loved Milani, especially their baked blushes, but I, too, have noticed a change in their product lip formulas. Thanks for sharing your honest thoughts with us, beauty, and I hope you have the most amazing week ahead!

XO,

Jalisa
www.thestylecontour.com

Ashley Sue said...

I haven't heard very good things about these either, and that's such a shame because the shades you have are so pretty! I was be annoyed with them drying patchy and being uneven!

Mica T said...

Dry is the main reason I haven't tried the matte lip trend too! Worried they'd have the problems you've shared here, such a shame all 3 are like that as the beautiful colour is well beautiful on you haha!

Hope you're having an awesome week :)

Away From The Blue Blog

jo said...

Oh no, for some reason they look kinda pasty to me. Thank you for your honest review, Kim! I can always count on you.

Btw, I noticed you're on Snapchat a lot. I deleted the app because one day I saw this cat filter, and I freaked out. LOL! Anyway, will activate it soon so I can see your snaps.

Have a lovely week!
Jo

http://www.whiterosesandcoffee.com/

E. Jonz said...

I never tried the Milani Matte Liquid Lipstick because I always hear mixed reviews on them. Thanks for sharing :)

Sharmili R said...

Okay, to be honest, I'm actually glad to hear that these aren't good lol. I have been wanting them forever but whenever I spot them in stores, they're all opened or sold out >:( At least now I know that I'm not missing out! It's a shame though, cause the colors themselves are really gorgeous :) Dearest in particular looks soo good on you!

Mili | Sharmtoaster

Ellese Launer said...

The dearest looks amazing on you but I totally trust your opinion when you say it is not too sweet! Too bad these are dry. Thanks for sharing honestly love. XO, Ellese

Rock.Paper.Glam.

Catherine Claire said...

Thanks for sharing! I love these lippies on you! will have to try! xo

Cathclaire | The Crystal Press
www.thecrystalpress.com
www.cathclaire.com

The Makeup Aficionado said...

These lipsticks look awesome!

www.themakeupaficionado.com

The Dragonfruit said...

Yikes! Definitely gonna have to stay away from these. Patchy drying liquid lipsticks are the WORST! Thanks for the honest review as always Kim ♥

The Dragonfruit Diaries
Visit my YouTube channel!

little luxury list said...

What a shame - the colors look lovely but I wouldn't be able to deal with uneven application and patchiness!

oomph. said...

it's a shame because these are beautiful colors. my favorite colourpop ultra satin lip dispenses a lot of product as well, but it's very forgiving. it doesn't dry super fast allowing you to wipe and correct.

FASHION TALES said...

What a pity about this overall but I have to say that these colours look great on you. I don't like dried formulas. I have only recently heard of Milani last year when my sister sent me lipsticks from them last year and I loved those colours. I haven't tried their liquid lipsticks. So now, I know to pass on them. :-)

Diva Desle said...

I totally agree with you Kim. A lot of cosmetic companies are pushing out trendy products quickly but they are compromising on quality. We need to be beauty savvy when we shop. Xoxo

Kay Cake said...

Oh, this has been on my wishlist! But now I have to think again before I place an order then.. The colors are pretty though ~

♡ http://kayxcake.blogspot.co.nz

Coco said...

I don't see the patchiness on your lips but I can definitely see it on your hand! I don't know many lipsticks showing this flaw, do you? Baci, Valeria - Coco et La vie en rose FASHION & BEAUTY

Lily A. said...

These colors are so pretty...too bad they aren't the best. I am not a fan of patchy lip products. Good thing I haven't spent any money on these. ;)
xo, Lily
Beauty With Lily

Penelope Sanchez said...

Love this lipstick. It doesn't flake and goes on wet. When it dries it looks absolutely beautiful. I love it. Milani is really good with most of their products. I've been satisfied with multiple purchases.

Penelope
Website