Butter London Abbey Rose Lippy Tinted Balm and Honey Pie & Naughty Biscuit Cheeky Cream Blush Review

Friday, March 27, 2015

Oh Butter London, how I LOVE your nail lacquers! But your makeup? I'm definitely NOT feeling the same kind of love. I'm so disappointed. Gorgeous and sophisticated packaging! Cute product names! But the formulas. Sigh. Let's begin.



Sweet-Bittersweet-NotSweet
supersweet(run & buy it) sweet(really good,buy it) bittersweet(ok, issues)not sweet(not good,don't buy this stuff)

Butter London Abbey Rose Lippy Tinted Balm - Not Sweet
It looks like a lipstick. It's packaged like a lipstick. It has color payoff like a lipstick. But it feels like a lip balm. And not a very good one. This tinted balm feels waxy, heavy and artificial on the lips. Abbey Rose is a beautiful shade that looks great (compliments most skin tones), but for me it didn't FEEL great. You can do better.

 Butter London Naughty Biscuit & Honey Pie Cheeky Cream Blushes - Not Sweet
There are several problems with these cream blushes. First, pigmentation. There's very little (if any) color payoff. You can apply all you want and the color never builds, which leads to the second problem. These blushes do not BLEND with your foundation makeup! You apply and they just sit atop your cheeks like wax. I blurred my photos on purpose so you could see where the blush stops under my eye. These cream blushes are waxy and when the sun hit your cheeks, you will GLOW (and not in a good way). Also, BOTH of these colors came off PINK on my cheeks. Honey Pie is not PINK. Naughty Biscuit is not PINK. So accuracy of color is the third issue. As Cher from Clueless would say, "From far away, it's okay, but up close it's a big old mess." HaHaHa To the makeup graveyard these blushes go (for me)! I'm trashing mine. That's how much I hate them. So glad I got these on sale. I can't recommend them. Have a great weekend :)

No Comments Yet, Leave Yours!

little luxury list said...

Yikes, what a disappointment! The colors look lovely,but it's too bad the formulation isn't there yet.

xoxo,
little luxury list formerly Chic 'n Cheap Living

Emmylou said...

I didn't know that Butter London has a makeup up line. Too bad it's not as good as the nail polishes...looks like they should've just stayed with nail stuff:P

Have a great Friday, Kim:)

Linda B said...

But...but...but...the packaging was so pretty :'(
Haha, that always makes me feel so sad. If it's presented so prettily, the product should really reflect that. Ah well, seems like it's not the case for these products, which makes me glad for reviewers like you! :)

The Dragonfruit Diaries

Kizzy Von Doll said...

Oh dear, what a nonsense!! Glad you got them on sale, but at the same time you still paid for nonsense...that's a shame!! I don't like lipsticks that feel like lip glosses as the colour doesn't apply right and moves all over your lips due to the greasiness!! Yuck!! Pretty packaging, but I will avoid these! Marvellous review doll :) xx

miss b said...

How disappointing! I didn't know they did make up but I know the nail polish is popular. A shame that you didn't like the texture of the lip balm as the colour looks so pretty on you and it looks a perfect even finish too! Have a great weekend!

Jackie Harrison said...

Great names for the product love the blushes, I'm the same if it does not feel right on the lips I do not want it. Great review Kim have a awesome weekend.

Candice Petersen said...

The shades are just so pretty

CANDICE | BEAUTY CANDY LOVES
♥♥♥

Lilli said...

Oh what a shame as the packaging and the shades you picked are so irresistible but definitely sound like something to avoid and a waste of money!:/ You know Kim, this hue of pink suits you so so much though, looking very cute!:) Have a great weekend you too, hugs! xo

Mica T said...

Oh such a shame the makeup is no good Kim, as I've heard people rave about the polishes. It's good you bought it on sale so you don't lose too much with them. I guess when you buy and try a large range of makeup, you're bound to come across a bad one or two! :(

Away From The Blue

Samantha Mariko said...

these are such pretty shades! they seem so useful with any kind of look, especially the blushes :)
www.samanthamariko.com

Cee said...

What a shame - although I have to say, I've always found Butter London's products to be overrated, particularly considering the crazy high price point.
xox,
Cee

Darcy said...

How disappointing! The colors are so pretty, too bad they are nto that great otherwise!
www.amemoryofus.com

Diana Ashuayem said...

Too bad you don't like this product, I love the lipstick/lipbalm on you!!
www.effortlesslady.com

Rowena @ rolala loves said...

What a letdown Kim! The packaging is really cute and the colors do look pretty on you despite the formulation glitches.

Rowena @ rolala loves

Shireen L. Platt said...

Oh gosh, I'm sorry these were such a disappointment! I had a tiny weeny sample of Butter London matte lipstick and I though it was okay so I have been looking forward to try their makeup range but will be skipping them for sure. Seems like they are trying to diversify their range but will definitely wait till they improvise on the formulas.

Shireen | Reflection of Sanity

Nerline Germain said...

Feeling waxy on the lips is never a good thing. Awww, I feel so bad. The lipstick looks good on you though. Happy weekend, girl!

Champagne Star said...

That lippy is such a pretty color, but too bad the quality isn't as good as the color.

Ashley said...

I think that lipstick looks super pretty on you Kim! Too bad the formula isn't good and it's uncomfortable to wear. And too bad about the blush too, I can't do cream blushes so that would be a disaster for me! I've never tried any of butter London makeup but your not the first person I've heard from that it's not as good as their nail polish

Miss Val's Creations said...

Great honest review! I do like the color names though. :)

Aimee said...

Such a shame that the products were disappointing, but love the lippy shade on you :) x

The Belle Narrative

Natalia | Fashioned by Love said...

What a shame! But on the other hand, good to know because I've been wondering if I should give their make-up a try... Thank you for an honest review, Kim! x

Missy May said...

Unfortunately not every product will meet our expectations. -Such as shame!
Great review!

missymayification.blogspot.co.uk

Y asmina said...

Such a shame when the packaging and products look really good at first glance!
http://yasminanicole.blogspot.co.uk

Gabrielle said...

I'm sorry to hear you were so disappointed with these products.. I hadn't even realised that Butter London did makeup, I feel behind the times now haha! The packaging - as you've said - is really rather lovely, so it's a pity what lies within has proved to be a disappointment for you!!

Gabrielle | A Glass Of Ice

x

Nastya Deutsch said...

Wow, what a beautiful lipstick!

With love, Nastya Deutsch ♥

http://nastyadeutsch.blogspot.ru/

Julie's Lifestyle said...

Wow I'm really surprised about the lipstick and blush! I too love their nail lacquers! Thanks for the review on these. Hope you are having a good weekend.
Julie xo

Joie Fatale said...

Man, that is disappointing. The lippy is nice and pink, and looks great, but, if it doesn't feel good, then not worth it.

PS LOVED the Clueless reference!

Tina Bradley said...

Too bad the rose tinted lip balm disappointed! It sure looks good on you, Kim. Oh, I bought me some NYX Wicked Lippies (2 of them) this weekend--post reading last week's review! :) T. http://tickledpinkwoman.blogspot.com

jo said...

Hi Kim, I never knew they made makeup. How disappointing! I think when company are good in one product, they should just stick to it rather than venturing out.

xo Jo

http://www.whiterosesandcoffee.com/

oomph. said...

the colors and packaging look nice and cute, but i'll take your word for it! thanks for sharing your thoughts on these.

Stanislava E. said...

Sorry to hear that these products disappointed you, Kim! You look cute though!

Margarita Bloom said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Margarita Bloom said...

Awww, poo. Darn it. SO pretty and the product turns out icky. Are their nail polishes good? I've been wanting to try out this pretty lavender one they have.

Regina / Head Glam Girl at Margarita Bloom
Margarita Bloom | Retro Vintage Skincare & Beauty
http://www.margarita-bloom.com/

***Enter our Kawaii Box Giveaway!! ***
Blog: http://www.cherrylipsblondecurls.com
Twitter: @mbglamourville @margaritabloom
Instagram: @margaritabloom

Rebeca Muñoz López said...

Too bad, because they have good presentation.

www.urbanikamoda.blogspot.com